# Should I Marry a Murderer? (2026)

> A pathologist confronts her fiancé's confession that he and his twin brother covered up a fatal hit-and-run in the Scottish Highlands.

Canonical page: https://ember.film/tv/1105160

## Facts

- Seasons: 1
- Episodes: 3
- Episode runtime: 50 min
- Status: Ended
- Genres: documentary, crime
- Created by: Josh Allott
- Network: Netflix
- Cast: Caroline Muirhead, Sandy McKellar, Stephen Muirhead, Margaret Muirhead, Ninon Noiret, James Crouch, Robert McKellar, Tony Parsons
- TMDB rating: 6.5/10
- IMDb: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt41082351/

## Ember's analysis

- Pacing: measured
- Intensity: strong
- Complexity: layered
- Violence: moderate
- Tone: sober, unsettling, intimate, tense, melancholic

## Synopsis

Should I Marry a Murderer? (2026) is a British true crime documentary miniseries created by Josh Allott for Netflix and produced by Candle True Stories. Across three fifty-minute episodes, pathologist Caroline Muirhead recounts the moment her fiancé, Scottish farmer Sandy McKellar, confessed that he and his twin brother Robert had killed cyclist Tony Parsons in a hit-and-run on the A82 near Bridge of Orchy and buried the body on the Auch Estate. The engine of the series is her attempt to reconcile the man she planned to marry with the crime he described, pieced together through interviews, reenactments performed by actors, archive footage, and testimony from her parents and the people around the case. Each episode lays out another layer of the story, moving between the rural Highland landscape, the estate, and the quiet domestic life that surrounded it. The tone is sober, unsettling and intimate, with a steady undercurrent of dread and moral unease rather than sensational spectacle. Viewers drawn to true crime docuseries will find resonance with The Jinx and Making a Murderer, and fans of The Staircase will recognize the same close, personal lens on a killing that tests a loved one's trust. It is a compact, character-driven watch for those who want a story about a real crime seen from inside a relationship.

## Shows like Should I Marry a Murderer?

- [One of Us (2016)](https://ember.film/tv/59025)
- [The Loch (2017)](https://ember.film/tv/62856)
- [The Woman in the Wall (2023)](https://ember.film/tv/131598)
- [The Victim (2019)](https://ember.film/tv/74817)
- [Traces (2019)](https://ember.film/tv/81304)
- [Guilt (2019)](https://ember.film/tv/80129)
- [Death of the Pastor's Wife (2026)](https://ember.film/tv/1105007)
- [In Plain Sight (2016)](https://ember.film/tv/60318)
- [The Ripper (2020)](https://ember.film/tv/94492)
- [Black Work (2015)](https://ember.film/tv/55561)

---

Site overview: https://ember.film/llms.txt