# I Love You, Now Die: The Commonwealth v. Michelle Carter (2019)

> A two-part HBO documentary revisits the Massachusetts case in which teenager Michelle Carter was tried over text messages sent to Conrad Roy before his death.

Canonical page: https://ember.film/tv/74315

## Facts

- Seasons: 1
- Episodes: 2
- Episode runtime: 70 min
- Status: Ended
- Genres: documentary, crime
- Created by: Erin Lee Carr
- Network: HBO
- Cast: Conrad Roy, Michelle Carter
- TMDB rating: 7.4/10
- IMDb: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9614090/

## Ember's analysis

- Pacing: measured
- Intensity: strong
- Complexity: layered
- Violence: none
- Tone: sober, probing, harrowing, contemplative, unsettling

## What critics say

Viewers broadly find this a balanced, careful account of an unprecedented and disturbing case, rated positively by the audience.

## Synopsis

I Love You, Now Die: The Commonwealth v. Michelle Carter (2019) is a United States true crime documentary miniseries created by Erin Lee Carr for HBO. Across two roughly seventy-minute episodes, the series revisits the prosecution of Michelle Carter, a teenager whose private text messages with Conrad Roy III became the central evidence in a case about whether words alone can carry criminal responsibility. Conrad Roy appears through archival footage, and Carter speaks as herself, so the viewer hears the people at the center of the story directly. The engine of the series is the slow reconstruction of a relationship conducted almost entirely through phones: messages are read aloud, weighed against testimony, and set against the courtroom arguments that followed. Its shape is that of a compact limited series, a single continuous inquiry rather than a case-of-the-week format. The tone is sober, probing and emotionally heavy, with an atmosphere of quiet unease as digital intimacy is pulled into public view. Viewers drawn to investigative documentaries will find resonance with Paradise Lost, The Staircase and Making a Murderer, all of which examine how a legal system interprets private lives. The series is set in contemporary Massachusetts, in the years around the events it documents, and it asks uncomfortable questions about adolescence, responsibility and the limits of the law.

## Shows like I Love You, Now Die: The Commonwealth v. Michelle Carter

- [Trial by Media (2020)](https://ember.film/tv/86181)
- [Killer Inside: The Mind of Aaron Hernandez (2020)](https://ember.film/tv/81842)
- [The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst (2015)](https://ember.film/tv/55155)
- [The Girl from Plainville (2022)](https://ember.film/tv/89470)
- [Making a Murderer (2015)](https://ember.film/tv/57018)
- [Allen v. Farrow (2021)](https://ember.film/tv/98406)
- [Death of the Pastor's Wife (2026)](https://ember.film/tv/1105007)
- [I'll Be Gone in the Dark (2020)](https://ember.film/tv/86274)
- [Devil in the Family: The Fall of Ruby Franke (2025)](https://ember.film/tv/187548)
- [American Murder: Laci Peterson (2024)](https://ember.film/tv/175260)

---

Site overview: https://ember.film/llms.txt